★ MONEY · COMPARISON #274 · RENT VS BUY

Rent vs Buy a Home Calculator: Which Costs Less in 2026?

On the defaults — $1,800.00 a month rent against a $400,000.00 home, 20% down, a 6.50% 30-year mortgage, over 7 years — renting wins by $16,254.78: cumulative rent $165,509.18 against a net buying cost of $181,763.96, with the breakeven year at year 10. Put in your own rent, price, and rate, and the calculator compares the two side by side, year by year, and finds the year buying wins. The existing mortgage payment calculator prices a monthly payment from a price and a rate; the existing mortgage affordability calculator sizes the loan from your income; the existing 15-year vs 30-year mortgage page compares two loan terms — none of them compares RENTING against BUYING over a horizon, and none finds the breakeven year. The existing guides (rent or buy: how to decide, rent vs buy home guide) explain the choice in words. This page replaces the previous simple /rent-vs-buy-calculator/ page, which compared only the monthly payment against the rent — no cumulative comparison and no breakeven year; this version adds the full cumulative cost comparison and the breakeven year.

1059

Rent vs buy a home calculator

The same home, the same horizon, on both sides. Mortgage: standard amortisation — monthly payment = loan × i ÷ (1 − (1+i)^−360), i = annual rate ÷ 12, 360 months for a 30-year loan; monthly interest is rounded to cents each month before the next balance, and the final month’s payment is adjusted to the remaining balance. Rent in year y = monthly rent × 12 × (1 + rent growth)^(y−1); cumulative rent is the sum over years 1..Y. Property tax and maintenance grow with the home value; homeowners insurance is flat per year. Home value at the end of year Y = price × (1 + appreciation)^Y; selling costs are 6% of that value. The opportunity cost of the down payment is simple: down payment × opportunity rate × years. Net cost of buying = down payment + mortgage payments + property tax + insurance + maintenance + opportunity cost − (sale value × (1 − selling cost) − remaining mortgage balance). Net cost of renting = cumulative rent. The gap = net buying cost − cumulative rent (positive means renting wins, negative means buying wins). The breakeven year is the FIRST year the gap turns negative.

The rent you would pay each month if you keep renting — the default is $1,800.00 a month.

The price of the home you would buy — the default is $400,000.00.

The down payment as a percent of the home price — 20% is $80,000.00 on the default home. The default is 20.

The annual mortgage rate — the default is 6.50% a year.

The length of the mortgage in years — the default is 30.

Property tax as a percent of the home value each year — the default is 1.10% a year.

Homeowners insurance per year — the default is $1,800.00 a year.

Maintenance as a percent of the home value each year — the default is 1.00% a year.

How fast the rent rises each year — the default is 3.00% a year.

How fast the home value rises each year — the default is 3.00% a year.

The cost of selling the home, as a percent of the sale price — the default is 6.00%.

What the down payment would earn invested each year — the default is 5.00% a year.

How many years to compare over — the default is 7.

Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (renting wins by $16,254.78), breakeven year 10Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (renting wins by $16,254.78), breakeven year 10Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (renting wins by $16,254.78), breakeven year 10. The monthly mortgage payment is $2,022.62 on a $320,000.00 loan at 6.50% over 30 years. The monthly owning cost in year 1 is $2,872.62 — higher than the $1,800.00 rent — but part of the payment is principal, which is equity, not cost. Over 7 years the rent adds up to $165,509.18 and buying costs $181,763.96 net, so renting wins by $16,254.78; buying wins from year 10.

Monthly rent: $1,800.00

Home price: $400,000.00

Down payment: $80,000.00

Down payment percent: 20%

Mortgage rate: 6.50%

Monthly mortgage payment: $2,022.62

Loan amount: $320,000.00

Monthly owning cost in year 1: $2,872.62

Cumulative rent over 7 years: $165,509.18

Net cost of buying over 7 years: $181,763.96

Gap at 7 years: $16,254.78

Winner at 7 years: renting wins by $16,254.78

Breakeven year: year 10

Year 1: cumulative rent $21,600.00, net buying cost $47,614.68, gap $26,014.68 (rent wins): Year 1: cumulative rent $21,600.00, net buying cost $47,614.68, gap $26,014.68 (rent wins)

Year 2: cumulative rent $43,848.00, net buying cost $70,903.44, gap $27,055.44 (rent wins): Year 2: cumulative rent $43,848.00, net buying cost $70,903.44, gap $27,055.44 (rent wins)

Year 3: cumulative rent $66,763.44, net buying cost $93,847.61, gap $27,084.17 (rent wins): Year 3: cumulative rent $66,763.44, net buying cost $93,847.61, gap $27,084.17 (rent wins)

Year 4: cumulative rent $90,366.34, net buying cost $116,427.43, gap $26,061.09 (rent wins): Year 4: cumulative rent $90,366.34, net buying cost $116,427.43, gap $26,061.09 (rent wins)

Year 5: cumulative rent $114,677.33, net buying cost $138,621.87, gap $23,944.54 (rent wins): Year 5: cumulative rent $114,677.33, net buying cost $138,621.87, gap $23,944.54 (rent wins)

Year 6: cumulative rent $139,717.65, net buying cost $160,408.61, gap $20,690.96 (rent wins): Year 6: cumulative rent $139,717.65, net buying cost $160,408.61, gap $20,690.96 (rent wins)

Year 7: cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (rent wins): Year 7: cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (rent wins)

Year 8: cumulative rent $192,074.46, net buying cost $202,662.72, gap $10,588.26 (rent wins): Year 8: cumulative rent $192,074.46, net buying cost $202,662.72, gap $10,588.26 (rent wins)

Year 9: cumulative rent $219,436.69, net buying cost $223,078.11, gap $3,641.42 (rent wins): Year 9: cumulative rent $219,436.69, net buying cost $223,078.11, gap $3,641.42 (rent wins)

Year 10: cumulative rent $247,619.79, net buying cost $242,981.69, gap -$4,638.10 (buy wins): Year 10: cumulative rent $247,619.79, net buying cost $242,981.69, gap -$4,638.10 (buy wins)

Year 11: cumulative rent $276,648.38, net buying cost $262,343.24, gap -$14,305.14 (buy wins): Year 11: cumulative rent $276,648.38, net buying cost $262,343.24, gap -$14,305.14 (buy wins)

Year 12: cumulative rent $306,547.83, net buying cost $281,130.64, gap -$25,417.19 (buy wins): Year 12: cumulative rent $306,547.83, net buying cost $281,130.64, gap -$25,417.19 (buy wins)

Year 13: cumulative rent $337,344.27, net buying cost $299,309.71, gap -$38,034.56 (buy wins): Year 13: cumulative rent $337,344.27, net buying cost $299,309.71, gap -$38,034.56 (buy wins)

Year 14: cumulative rent $369,064.60, net buying cost $316,844.15, gap -$52,220.45 (buy wins): Year 14: cumulative rent $369,064.60, net buying cost $316,844.15, gap -$52,220.45 (buy wins)

Year 15: cumulative rent $401,736.54, net buying cost $333,695.31, gap -$68,041.23 (buy wins): Year 15: cumulative rent $401,736.54, net buying cost $333,695.31, gap -$68,041.23 (buy wins)

Branch: Rent $1,200/month: Rent $1,200.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $110,339.46, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $71,424.50 (renting wins by $71,424.50), breakeven year 22

Branch: Home price $300,000: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $300,000.00 home, 20% down ($60,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,516.96, year-1 owning cost $2,191.96, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $139,473.06, gap -$26,036.12 (buying wins by $26,036.12), breakeven year 4

Branch: Mortgage rate 5.00%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,717.83, year-1 owning cost $2,567.83, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $148,253.86, gap -$17,255.32 (buying wins by $17,255.32), breakeven year 5

Branch: Rent growth 5.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $175,867.39, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $5,896.57 (renting wins by $5,896.57), breakeven year 8

Branch: Home appreciation 0.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $262,631.83, gap $97,122.65 (renting wins by $97,122.65), breakeven year 25

Branch: Down payment 10%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 10% down ($40,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,275.44, year-1 owning cost $3,125.44, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $185,168.14, gap $19,658.96 (renting wins by $19,658.96), breakeven year 10

Reverse: Monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 years: $1,976.78

Reverse: Monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 years: (rounded): $1,976.78

Exact monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 years: 1976.7793

At $1,976.78 the figures are: Rent $1,976.78/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $181,764.02, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap -$0.06 (buying wins by $0.06), breakeven year 7

At the lower neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,975.78/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $181,672.08, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $91.88 (renting wins by $91.88), breakeven year 8

At the upper neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,977.78/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $181,855.97, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap -$92.01 (buying wins by $92.01), breakeven year 7

Reverse verdict: CONTINUOUS

Reverse: Home price for an exact tie at 7 years: $361,564.47

Reverse: Home price for an exact tie at 7 years: (rounded): $361,564.47

Exact home price for an exact tie at 7 years: 361564.4690

At $361,564.47 the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $361,564.47 home, 20% down ($72,312.89), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,828.27, year-1 owning cost $2,611.01, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,509.18, gap $0.00 (tie), breakeven year 8

At the lower neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $360,564.47 home, 20% down ($72,112.89), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,823.21, year-1 owning cost $2,604.20, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,086.28, gap -$422.90 (buying wins by $422.90), breakeven year 7

At the upper neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $362,564.47 home, 20% down ($72,512.89), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,833.32, year-1 owning cost $2,617.81, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,932.16, gap $422.98 (renting wins by $422.98), breakeven year 8

Reverse verdict: CONTINUOUS

Reverse: Mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 years: 5.78%

Reverse: Mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 years: (rounded): 5.78%

Exact mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 years: 5.7753

At 5.78% the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.78% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,873.54, year-1 owning cost $2,723.54, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,614.15, gap $104.97 (renting wins by $104.97), breakeven year 8

At the lower neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.77% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,871.50, year-1 owning cost $2,721.50, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,390.78, gap -$118.40 (buying wins by $118.40), breakeven year 7

At the upper neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.79% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,875.57, year-1 owning cost $2,725.57, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,837.77, gap $328.59 (renting wins by $328.59), breakeven year 8

Reverse verdict: CONTINUOUS

Reverse: Home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 years: 3.54%

Reverse: Home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 years: (rounded): 3.54%

Exact home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 years: 3.5428

At 3.54% the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,585.48, gap $76.30 (renting wins by $76.30), breakeven year 8

At the lower neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,889.84, gap $380.66 (renting wins by $380.66), breakeven year 8

At the upper neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,280.92, gap -$228.26 (buying wins by $228.26), breakeven year 7

Reverse verdict: CONTINUOUS

Reverse: Breakeven year (first year buying wins): year 10

Reverse: Breakeven year (first year buying wins): (rounded): year 10

Exact breakeven year (first year buying wins): 10

Reverse verdict: STEP

Reverse: Selling cost for an exact tie at 7 years: 2.70%

Reverse: Selling cost for an exact tie at 7 years: (rounded): 2.70%

Exact selling cost for an exact tie at 7 years: 2.6956

At 2.70% the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,529.62, gap $20.44 (renting wins by $20.44), breakeven year 8

At the lower neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,480.43, gap -$28.75 (buying wins by $28.75), breakeven year 7

At the upper neighbor the figures are: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,578.82, gap $69.64 (renting wins by $69.64), breakeven year 8

Reverse verdict: CONTINUOUS

Edge: Rent $0: Rent $0.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $0.00, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $181,763.96 (renting wins by $181,763.96), breakeven never

Edge: Home appreciation -3.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $329,795.09, gap $164,285.91 (renting wins by $164,285.91), breakeven year 30

Edge: Mortgage rate 0.00%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 0.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $888.89, year-1 owning cost $1,738.89, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $42,532.13, gap -$122,977.05 (buying wins by $122,977.05), breakeven year 2

Edge: Home price $1,000,000: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $1,000,000.00 home, 20% down ($200,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $5,056.54, year-1 owning cost $6,956.54, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $435,510.06, gap $270,000.88 (renting wins by $270,000.88), breakeven never

Edge: Rent growth 0.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $151,200.00, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $30,563.96 (renting wins by $30,563.96), breakeven year 17

Edge: Down payment 0%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 0% down ($0.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,528.27, year-1 owning cost $3,378.27, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $188,572.06, gap $23,062.88 (renting wins by $23,062.88), breakeven year 11

Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (renting wins by $16,254.78), breakeven year 10. On the defaults renting wins at 7 years by $16,254.78 — but the gap peaks in year 3 at $27,084.17 and then shrinks every year, and buying wins from year 10. At 15 years buying wins by $68,041.23.

Rent $1,200/month: Rent $1,200.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $110,339.46, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $71,424.50 (renting wins by $71,424.50), breakeven year 22.

Home price $300,000: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $300,000.00 home, 20% down ($60,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,516.96, year-1 owning cost $2,191.96, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $139,473.06, gap -$26,036.12 (buying wins by $26,036.12), breakeven year 4.

Mortgage rate 5.00%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,717.83, year-1 owning cost $2,567.83, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $148,253.86, gap -$17,255.32 (buying wins by $17,255.32), breakeven year 5.

Rent growth 5.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $175,867.39, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $5,896.57 (renting wins by $5,896.57), breakeven year 8.

Home appreciation 0.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $262,631.83, gap $97,122.65 (renting wins by $97,122.65), breakeven year 25.

Down payment 10%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 10% down ($40,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,275.44, year-1 owning cost $3,125.44, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $185,168.14, gap $19,658.96 (renting wins by $19,658.96), breakeven year 10.

Reverse: the monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 years is $1,976.78 (exact 1976.7793); at $1,976.78 the gap is -$0.06 — verdict: CONTINUOUS. The home price for an exact tie at 7 years is $361,564.47 (exact 361564.4690); at $361,564.47 the gap is $0.00 — verdict: CONTINUOUS. The mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 years is 5.78% (exact 5.7753%); at 5.78% the gap is $104.97 — verdict: CONTINUOUS. The home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 years is 3.54% (exact 3.5428%); at 3.54% the gap is $76.30 — verdict: CONTINUOUS. The breakeven year is year 10 (year 9 gap $3,641.42; year 10 gap -$4,638.10) — verdict: STEP. The selling cost for an exact tie at 7 years is 2.70% (exact 2.6956%); at 2.70% the gap is $20.44 — verdict: CONTINUOUS.

Edges: rent of $0 gives Rent $0.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $0.00, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $181,763.96 (renting wins by $181,763.96), breakeven never. Home appreciation of −3.00%/yr gives Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $329,795.09, gap $164,285.91 (renting wins by $164,285.91), breakeven year 30. A mortgage rate of 0.00% gives Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 0.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $888.89, year-1 owning cost $1,738.89, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $42,532.13, gap -$122,977.05 (buying wins by $122,977.05), breakeven year 2. A home price of $1,000,000 gives Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $1,000,000.00 home, 20% down ($200,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $5,056.54, year-1 owning cost $6,956.54, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $435,510.06, gap $270,000.88 (renting wins by $270,000.88), breakeven never. Rent growth of 0.00%/yr gives Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $151,200.00, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $30,563.96 (renting wins by $30,563.96), breakeven year 17. A down payment of 0% gives Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 0% down ($0.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,528.27, year-1 owning cost $3,378.27, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $188,572.06, gap $23,062.88 (renting wins by $23,062.88), breakeven year 11.

How renting compares with buying

On the defaults — $1,800.00 a month rent against a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), a 6.50% 30-year mortgage, over 7 years — the monthly mortgage payment is $2,022.62 (loan $320,000.00), the monthly owning cost in year 1 is $2,872.62 (payment $2,022.62 + tax $366.67 + insurance $150.00 + maintenance $333.33) against rent of $1,800.00, the cumulative rent is $165,509.18, and the net cost of buying is $181,763.96. Renting wins by $16,254.78 at 7 years, and the breakeven year is year 10 — at year 9 renting still wins by $3,641.42; at year 10 buying wins by $4,638.10; at 15 years buying wins by $68,041.23.

Five things about the model are worth stating plainly. First, the monthly owning cost in year 1 is higher than the rent, but part of the mortgage payment is principal — equity, not cost — which is why the monthly comparison misleads and the cumulative comparison is the honest one. Second, the gap peaks in year 3 ($27,084.17) and then shrinks every year — buying starts behind and catches up. Third, the net buying cost subtracts the equity you get back when you sell: after 7 years the home is worth $491,949.55, selling costs take 6%, and the remaining mortgage balance is $289,331.75, so $173,100.82 comes back. Fourth, the down payment has an opportunity cost — $80,000.00 at 5.00% a year for 7 years is $28,000.00 of earnings given up. And fifth, this ignores renter’s insurance, moving costs, HOA dues, home improvements, and tax deductions (e.g. the mortgage-interest deduction); rent and home prices are assumed to grow smoothly at the rates you enter, which real markets do not do; the opportunity rate is your guess at what the down payment would earn invested; all listed in Accuracy & limitations.

This calculator is part of the X vs Y comparisons library — the same compare-both-sides format as the personal loan vs credit card and 15-year vs 30-year mortgage calculators.

Year by year, on the defaults

YearCumulative rentNet cost of buyingGapWinner
Year 1$21,600.00$47,614.68$26,014.68rent wins
Year 2$43,848.00$70,903.44$27,055.44rent wins
Year 3$66,763.44$93,847.61$27,084.17rent wins
Year 4$90,366.34$116,427.43$26,061.09rent wins
Year 5$114,677.33$138,621.87$23,944.54rent wins
Year 6$139,717.65$160,408.61$20,690.96rent wins
Year 7$165,509.18$181,763.96$16,254.78rent wins
Year 8$192,074.46$202,662.72$10,588.26rent wins
Year 9$219,436.69$223,078.11$3,641.42rent wins
Year 10$247,619.79$242,981.69-$4,638.10buy wins
Year 11$276,648.38$262,343.24-$14,305.14buy wins
Year 12$306,547.83$281,130.64-$25,417.19buy wins
Year 13$337,344.27$299,309.71-$38,034.56buy wins
Year 14$369,064.60$316,844.15-$52,220.45buy wins
Year 15$401,736.54$333,695.31-$68,041.23buy wins

The gap peaks in year 3 ($27,084.17) and then shrinks every year — buying starts behind and catches up.

The worked example, line by line

Setup: $1,800.00 a month rent; a $400,000.00 home; 20% down ($80,000.00); a 6.50% 30-year mortgage; 1.10% property tax; $1,800.00 a year insurance; 1.00% maintenance; 3.00% rent growth; 3.00% appreciation; 6.00% selling cost; 5.00% opportunity rate; 7 years.

Line 1 — the mortgage payment. The loan is $400,000.00 − $80,000.00 = $320,000.00, and the monthly payment is $2,022.62. Over 7 years the payments add up to $169,900.08.

Line 2 — the running costs. Property tax, insurance, and maintenance over 7 years add up to $76,964.70 — tax starts at $4,400.00 a year and grows with the home value, insurance is flat at $1,800.00 a year, and maintenance starts at $4,000.00 a year.

Line 3 — the opportunity cost. The $80,000.00 down payment at 5.00% a year for 7 years costs $28,000.00 in earnings given up.

Line 4 — the equity back. After 7 years the home is worth $491,949.55; selling costs of 6% leave $462,432.57, and after the remaining mortgage balance of $289,331.75 the equity back is $173,100.82.

Line 5 — the net buying cost. Down payment $80,000.00 + payments $169,900.08 + running costs $76,964.70 + opportunity cost $28,000.00 − equity back $173,100.82 = $181,763.96.

Line 6 — the rent side and the gap. Cumulative rent over 7 years is $165,509.18, so the gap is $181,763.96 − $165,509.18 = $16,254.78 — renting wins by $16,254.78.

Every branch, checked

Rent $1,200/month: Rent $1,200.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $110,339.46, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $71,424.50 (renting wins by $71,424.50), breakeven year 22 — Cheaper rent keeps renting ahead for decades — even at 15 years renting still wins by $65,870.94, and buying only breaks even in year 22. At 10 years the gap is $77,901.83; at 15 years it is $65,870.94; the breakeven year is year 22.

Home price $300,000: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $300,000.00 home, 20% down ($60,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,516.96, year-1 owning cost $2,191.96, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $139,473.06, gap -$26,036.12 (buying wins by $26,036.12), breakeven year 4 — A cheaper home flips the answer — buying wins at 7 years by $26,036.12 and breaks even in year 4. At 10 years the gap is -$60,883.34; at 15 years it is -$144,714.51; the breakeven year is year 4.

Mortgage rate 5.00%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,717.83, year-1 owning cost $2,567.83, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $148,253.86, gap -$17,255.32 (buying wins by $17,255.32), breakeven year 5 — A lower rate cuts the payment to $1,717.83 — buying wins at 7 years by $17,255.32 and breaks even in year 5. At 10 years the gap is -$52,201.58; at 15 years it is -$137,863.62; the breakeven year is year 5.

Rent growth 5.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $175,867.39, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $5,896.57 (renting wins by $5,896.57), breakeven year 8 — Faster-rising rent closes the gap — 7-year rent is $175,867.39, renting wins by only $5,896.57 at 7 years, and buying breaks even in year 8. At 10 years the gap is -$28,700.80; at 15 years it is -$132,401.67; the breakeven year is year 8.

Home appreciation 0.00%/yr: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $262,631.83, gap $97,122.65 (renting wins by $97,122.65), breakeven year 25 — A flat home price kills the equity story — renting wins by $97,122.65 at 7 years and buying only breaks even in year 25. At 10 years the gap is $112,377.85; at 15 years it is $111,523.62; the breakeven year is year 25.

Down payment 10%: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 10% down ($40,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,275.44, year-1 owning cost $3,125.44, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $185,168.14, gap $19,658.96 (renting wins by $19,658.96), breakeven year 10 — Less money down means a bigger loan and a $2,275.44 payment — renting wins by $19,658.96 at 7 years, and buying only just wins at year 10, by $388.02. At 10 years the gap is -$388.02; at 15 years it is -$63,507.71; the breakeven year is year 10.

The reverses, worked backwards

Monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 years: $1,976.78 — the exact rent is 1976.7793. At the displayed $1,976.78 the gap is −$0.06 (buying wins by six cents — effectively a tie). $1,975.78 gives a gap of $91.88; $1,977.78 gives a gap of −$92.01. The star is DOLLARS.

Home price for an exact tie at 7 years: $361,564.47 — the exact price is 361564.4690. At the displayed $361,564.47 the gap is $0.00. $360,564.47 gives a gap of −$422.90; $362,564.47 gives a gap of $422.98. The star is DOLLARS.

Mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 years: 5.78% — the exact rate is 5.7753%. At the displayed 5.78% the gap is $104.97 (rent still wins by $104.97 — the displayed rate is just above the exact tie). 5.77% gives a gap of −$118.40; 5.79% gives a gap of $328.59. The star is RATE.

Home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 years: 3.54% — the exact appreciation is 3.5428%. At the displayed 3.54% the gap is $76.30 (rent still wins by $76.30). 3.53% gives a gap of $380.66; 3.55% gives a gap of −$228.26. The star is RATE.

Breakeven year: year 10 is the first year buying wins (year 9 gap $3,641.42; year 10 gap −$4,638.10). The breakeven is a whole year — there is no fractional year; year 10 is the smallest whole year where buying wins. The star is YEARS.

Selling cost for an exact tie at 7 years: 2.70% — the exact selling cost is 2.6956%. At the displayed 2.70% the gap is $20.44 (rent still wins by $20.44). 2.69% gives a gap of −$28.75; 2.71% gives a gap of $69.64. The star is RATE.

What the defaults assume

The defaults are $1,800.00 a month rent against a $400,000.00 home, 20% down, a 6.50% 30-year mortgage, over 7 years — renting wins by $16,254.78 and the breakeven year is year 10. With rent of $1,200.00 a month, Rent $1,200.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $110,339.46, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $71,424.50 (renting wins by $71,424.50), breakeven year 22 — buying only breaks even in year 22. With rent of $0, Rent $0.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $0.00, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $181,763.96 (renting wins by $181,763.96), breakeven never — free rent always wins. With home appreciation of −3.00% a year, Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $329,795.09, gap $164,285.91 (renting wins by $164,285.91), breakeven year 30 — the breakeven year is 30. With a mortgage rate of 0.00%, Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 0.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $888.89, year-1 owning cost $1,738.89, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $42,532.13, gap -$122,977.05 (buying wins by $122,977.05), breakeven year 2 — the payment is $888.89. With a $1,000,000.00 home, Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $1,000,000.00 home, 20% down ($200,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $5,056.54, year-1 owning cost $6,956.54, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $435,510.06, gap $270,000.88 (renting wins by $270,000.88), breakeven never — buying never breaks even in 30 years. With rent growth of 0.00% a year, Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $151,200.00, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $30,563.96 (renting wins by $30,563.96), breakeven year 17 — 7-year rent is $151,200.00. With a down payment of 0%, Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 0% down ($0.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,528.27, year-1 owning cost $3,378.27, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $188,572.06, gap $23,062.88 (renting wins by $23,062.88), breakeven year 11 — the payment is $2,528.27.

Output · formula · meaning

OutputFormulaWhat it means
Monthly rentinput$1,800.00.
Home priceinput$400,000.00.
Down payment20% of the home price$80,000.00.
Loan amountprice − down payment$320,000.00.
Monthly mortgage paymentloan × i ÷ (1 − (1+i)^−360)$2,022.62.
Monthly owning cost, year 1payment + tax + insurance + maintenance$2,872.62.
Cumulative rent, 7 yearssum of rent over years 1..7$165,509.18.
Net cost of buying, 7 yearsdown + payments + tax + insurance + maintenance + opportunity cost − equity back$181,763.96.
Gap at 7 yearsnet buying cost − cumulative rent$16,254.78.
Winner at 7 yearslower net cost winsrenting wins by $16,254.78.
Breakeven yearfirst year the gap turns negativeyear 10.
Monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 yearsexact 1976.7793$1,976.78 → $1,976.78.
Below the revr1 starneighborRent $1,975.78/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $181,672.08, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $91.88 (renting wins by $91.88), breakeven year 8.
Above the revr1 starneighborRent $1,977.78/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $181,855.97, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap -$92.01 (buying wins by $92.01), breakeven year 7.
Home price for an exact tie at 7 yearsexact 361564.4690$361,564.47 → $361,564.47.
Below the revr2 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $360,564.47 home, 20% down ($72,112.89), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,823.21, year-1 owning cost $2,604.20, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,086.28, gap -$422.90 (buying wins by $422.90), breakeven year 7.
Above the revr2 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $362,564.47 home, 20% down ($72,512.89), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,833.32, year-1 owning cost $2,617.81, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,932.16, gap $422.98 (renting wins by $422.98), breakeven year 8.
Mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 yearsexact 5.77535.78% → 5.78%.
Below the revr3 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.77% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,871.50, year-1 owning cost $2,721.50, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,390.78, gap -$118.40 (buying wins by $118.40), breakeven year 7.
Above the revr3 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.79% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,875.57, year-1 owning cost $2,725.57, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,837.77, gap $328.59 (renting wins by $328.59), breakeven year 8.
Home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 yearsexact 3.54283.54% → 3.54%.
Below the revr4 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,889.84, gap $380.66 (renting wins by $380.66), breakeven year 8.
Above the revr4 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,280.92, gap -$228.26 (buying wins by $228.26), breakeven year 7.
Breakeven year (first year buying wins)exact 10year 10 → year 10.
Selling cost for an exact tie at 7 yearsexact 2.69562.70% → 2.70%.
Below the revr6 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,480.43, gap -$28.75 (buying wins by $28.75), breakeven year 7.
Above the revr6 starneighborRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $165,578.82, gap $69.64 (renting wins by $69.64), breakeven year 8.
Rent $1,200/monthsame modelRent $1,200.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $110,339.46, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $71,424.50 (renting wins by $71,424.50), breakeven year 22.
Home price $300,000same modelRent $1,800.00/month vs a $300,000.00 home, 20% down ($60,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,516.96, year-1 owning cost $2,191.96, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $139,473.06, gap -$26,036.12 (buying wins by $26,036.12), breakeven year 4.
Mortgage rate 5.00%same modelRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 5.00% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $1,717.83, year-1 owning cost $2,567.83, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $148,253.86, gap -$17,255.32 (buying wins by $17,255.32), breakeven year 5.
Rent growth 5.00%/yrsame modelRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $175,867.39, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $5,896.57 (renting wins by $5,896.57), breakeven year 8.
Home appreciation 0.00%/yrsame modelRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $262,631.83, gap $97,122.65 (renting wins by $97,122.65), breakeven year 25.
Down payment 10%same modelRent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 10% down ($40,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,275.44, year-1 owning cost $3,125.44, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $185,168.14, gap $19,658.96 (renting wins by $19,658.96), breakeven year 10.

Who uses this

  • The renter paying $1,800.00 a month: they learn renting wins by $16,254.78 at 7 years but buying wins from year 10 — and they check the $1,976.78 reverse to see the rent that ties buying.
  • The buyer looking at a $300,000.00 home: they learn buying wins at 7 years by $26,036.12 — and they check the $361,564.47 reverse to see the price that ties the two.
  • The buyer with a 5.00% rate: they learn a lower rate cuts the payment to $1,717.83 and buying wins at 7 years by $17,255.32 — and they check the 5.78% reverse to see the rate that ties the two.
  • The buyer with only 10% down: they learn renting still wins at 7 years by $19,658.96 — and they check the 2.70% reverse to see the selling cost that ties the two.

Accuracy & limitations

The math is first-principles: standard amortisation with monthly interest rounded to cents, rent and home value grown year by year at the rates you enter, and the gap taken from the two rounded totals. What the model cannot do is predict real markets: it does NOT model renter’s insurance, moving costs, HOA dues, or home improvements; it does NOT model tax deductions such as the mortgage-interest deduction; it assumes rent and home prices grow smoothly at the rates you enter, which real markets do not do; and the opportunity rate is your guess at what the down payment would earn invested. A home you live in for 3 years behaves very differently from one you live in for 15 — the horizon is the decision. Use it to find your breakeven year — then check real listings and real rates before you decide.

Cite this calculatorBright Side Kit. “Rent vs Buy a Home Calculator: Which Costs Less in 2026?” brightoolbox.com, 2026. Method: monthly mortgage payment = loan × i ÷ (1 − (1+i)^−360), i = annual rate ÷ 12; monthly interest is rounded to cents each month before the next balance. Rent in year y = monthly rent × 12 × (1 + rent growth)^(y−1); cumulative rent is the sum over years 1..Y. Property tax and maintenance grow with the home value; homeowners insurance is flat per year. Home value at the end of year Y = price × (1 + appreciation)^Y; selling costs are 6% of that value. The opportunity cost of the down payment is down payment × opportunity rate × years. Net cost of buying = down payment + mortgage payments + property tax + insurance + maintenance + opportunity cost − (sale value × (1 − selling cost) − remaining mortgage balance). The gap = net buying cost − cumulative rent (positive means renting wins). The breakeven year is the first year the gap turns negative. Reverses: the monthly rent for an exact tie at 7 years is $1,976.78 (exact 1976.7793; at $1,976.78 the gap is −$0.06); the home price for an exact tie at 7 years is $361,564.47 (exact 361564.4690; at $361,564.47 the gap is $0.00); the mortgage rate for an exact tie at 7 years is 5.78% (exact 5.7753%; at 5.78% the gap is $104.97); the home appreciation for an exact tie at 7 years is 3.54% (exact 3.5428%; at 3.54% the gap is $76.30); the breakeven year is year 10 (year 9 gap $3,641.42; year 10 gap −$4,638.10); the selling cost for an exact tie at 7 years is 2.70% (exact 2.6956%; at 2.70% the gap is $20.44). Defaults: Rent $1,800.00/month vs a $400,000.00 home, 20% down ($80,000.00), 6.50% 30-year mortgage, 7-year horizon: monthly payment $2,022.62, year-1 owning cost $2,872.62, cumulative rent $165,509.18, net buying cost $181,763.96, gap $16,254.78 (renting wins by $16,254.78), breakeven year 10. Bright Side Kit. "Rent vs Buy a Home Calculator: Which Costs Less in 2026?" https://brightoolbox.com/rent-vs-buy-calculator/ Accessed October 26, 2026.
Embed this calculator

Frequently asked questions

Is it cheaper to rent or buy a $400,000 home?

At 7 years renting wins by $16,254.78; from year 10 buying wins. Cumulative rent over 7 years is $165,509.18 and the net buying cost is $181,763.96 — at 15 years buying wins by $68,041.23.

What is the breakeven year for rent vs buy?

Year 10. At year 9 renting still wins by $3,641.42; at year 10 buying wins by $4,638.10. The gap peaks in year 3 at $27,084.17 and shrinks every year after.

Why is owning more per month but cheaper long-term?

Because part of the payment is principal — equity, not cost. The year-1 owning cost is $2,872.62 a month against $1,800.00 rent, but after 7 years $173,100.82 of equity comes back when you sell.

What rent ties buying at 7 years?

$1,976.78 a month. The exact rent is 1976.7793; at the displayed $1,976.78 the gap is −$0.06 — effectively a tie.

What if the home is $300,000 instead?

Buying wins at 7 years by $26,036.12. The payment is $1,516.96 and the breakeven year is 4.

What if the mortgage rate is 5% instead of 6.5%?

Buying wins at 7 years by $17,255.32. The payment is $1,717.83 and the breakeven year is 5.

What does the calculator leave out?

Renter’s insurance, moving costs, HOA dues, home improvements, and tax deductions. It also assumes rent and home prices grow smoothly at the rates you enter, which real markets do not do.

Does a bigger down payment help?

Yes, but slowly. With 10% down instead of 20%, renting still wins at 7 years by $19,658.96, and buying only just wins at year 10, by $388.02.